Grammarly and ProWritingAid are the two names every writer hears first, and for everyday prose they are close competitors. For a novel, the differences matter. Here is the comparison from a novelist's seat, with a disclosure: Authors Starport makes an editing suite that competes with both, so treat our view of where they stop as a maker's case.
Rival features above are as listed on Grammarly's plans page and ProWritingAid's pricing page on October 20, 2026.
| Category | ProWritingAid | Grammarly |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Writing assistant with fiction-relevant reports and a Story Critique group of tools | A writing tool |
| Grammar and spelling | Grammar, spelling and punctuation checks, including on the free plan | Free plan listed at $0 per month |
| Style reports | Premium lists 25+ writing analysis reports and a custom style guide | Pro lists tone adjustment, full-sentence rewrites and unlimited personalized suggestions |
| Fiction awareness | Premium lists a comparison of your writing with 90 fiction authors across genres | No fiction-specific reports are listed on its plans page |
| Where it runs | Web editor, Word, Google Docs, Scrivener | Check Grammarly's site for current integrations |
| Story and structure | Story Critique tools: Chapter Critique, Plot Analysis, Character Analysis, Manuscript Analysis (credits), Virtual Beta Reader, Marketability Analysis | None listed on its plans page |
| Makes the edits? | Suggestions and Rephrases; the manuscript edit is still yours | Full-sentence rewrites on Pro; the manuscript edit is still yours |
| Pricing | Both have a free plan and paid plans set by the vendor, which change. Check each site; we don't quote rivals' prices. | |
Do you write in Scrivener? ProWritingAid lists Scrivener among its integrations. Is most of your writing email, marketing and blurbs? Grammarly's Pro plan lists tone adjustment and full-sentence rewrites. Do you have a distinctive voice? Be careful with either: accepting suggestions wholesale across a manuscript can sand a voice down, so treat reports as information rather than instructions.
And the question both leave to you: does the story work? ProWritingAid's Story Critique tools, including Manuscript Analysis, sell a story-level read with credits, though its own page says that is not meant to replace a human developmental editor or beta reader. Grammarly's plans page lists nothing at that level. A manuscript can pass both clean and still lose readers by chapter three. That read is a developmental edit, from a human or from a story-level tool such as Authors Starport's Developmental Critique.
Starport isn't a typing assistant and doesn't try to be; keep Grammarly or ProWritingAid for that. It reads a finished draft whole and does the jobs neither lists: the structural critique, a Style Sheet reverse-engineered from your own prose, a line edit rendered as tracked changes in your Word file against that sheet, a Scene Map, and an Instant Score. If you're weighing the two grammar tools because the book itself needs help, the free Manuscript Scorecard is the cheaper first step — and it'll tell you which problem you actually have. See also our Grammarly alternatives for novelists shortlist.
Authors Starport is a full editing suite — developmental critique, a line edit delivered as tracked changes, a style sheet built from your own prose, a scene map and an instant score — and every one of those tools is grounded in what real readers actually respond to. Behind them sit real reader reviews, book blurbs analyzed for hook, stakes and tone, and reader personas built from that data.
Compared with ProWritingAid and Grammarly, which are subscription tools that suggest changes for you to apply, Starport builds a Style Sheet from your manuscript and returns the line edit as tracked changes in your Word file.
The Manuscript Scorecard grades your full manuscript on nine craft metrics, measures it against a reference set of Coral Hart's prose, and tells you exactly what to fix first. Free, in minutes.
Get your free Manuscript Scorecard →ProWritingAid, for the manuscript itself: Premium lists 25+ analysis reports, it lists a Story Critique group of tools, and it works inside Scrivener and Word. Neither lists a line edit returned as tracked changes, and Grammarly's plans page lists no story-level analysis. Checked October 20, 2026.
Its plans page lists tone adjustment and full-sentence rewrites on Pro and no fiction-specific reports. Accepting suggestions wholesale across a manuscript can flatten voice, so use it selectively on the book itself.
You can, though they overlap on grammar. A more useful pairing is one grammar tool plus something that does a different job: a developmental read, or a line editor that works from your own style sheet, such as Authors Starport.
Both have free tiers and paid plans that the vendors change regularly, so check each site for current pricing rather than trusting a comparison page. Authors Starport's pricing is on our plans page and is pay-as-you-go by tool.