← All guides
Tools, compared

Fictionary alternative: four options, what each does and costs

A good Fictionary alternative depends on who should do the reading: ProWritingAid, AutoCrit and Marlowe return story feedback on a whole manuscript, while Authors Starport hands back an editorial letter and a scene-by-scene map written for romance.

Authors Starport is a competing tool, so this page is a maker's case, not a neutral review. Every price and feature below for another tool is what that company lists on its own site as of October 20, 2026. Plans change, so check the linked page before you buy.

What does Fictionary do today?

Fictionary StoryTeller is structural self-editing software. As listed on its StoryTeller page and its pricing page on October 20, 2026, it includes:

  • Genre-specific templates.
  • Scene feedback. Its page says it gives feedback on each scene for goal, word count, tension and conflict.
  • Visualizations. 15 of them, plus a Story Map that gives an overview of your whole story.
  • A step-by-step Story Editing Journey.

In our reading, the trade is effort. The software gives you insights and a step-by-step journey, and you turn them into edits scene by scene. That suits authors who want to learn structural editing, and its pricing page calls it story structure software for DIY writers.

How much does Fictionary cost?

PlanBilled monthlyBilled annuallyWhat its pages list
StoryTeller$19 per month$14 per month ($168 a year)Genre-specific templates, feedback on each scene, 15 story insights, a Story Editing Journey, 3 manuscripts at a time
StoryTeller Premium$39 per month$29 per month ($348 a year)Everything in StoryTeller plus track changes and comments, 10 manuscripts at a time, and a listing as ideal for creating a series

Fictionary lists all plans in USD with a free trial of 7 days and no credit card required. Sources: Fictionary pricing and StoryTeller page, checked October 20, 2026.

Which Fictionary alternative fits which job?

ToolWhat its own site says it doesPrice as listed
ProWritingAidStory-level reports (Manuscript Analysis, Plot Analysis, Character Analysis, Virtual Beta Reader) sold with credits, on top of grammar and style checks. Its Manuscript Analysis page says it is not meant to replace a human developmental editor or beta readerFree plan. Premium $10 per month billed yearly, or $30 billed monthly. Credits are separate
AutoCritStory Analyzer+ covering premise and plot, conflict, characters, timeline, foreshadowing and genre analysis, plus automated alpha and beta readersFree plan. Pro $30 per month, or $15 per month billed annually
Marlowe (Authors A.I.)A developmental report on plot, character, pacing, story beats, narrative drive and theme, compared with bestsellers in your genre, including romanceReports start at $29.95 for a single report
Authors StarportA Developmental Critique (an editorial letter with a verdict, ranked problems and chapter-by-chapter notes) and a Scene Map (every scene scored keep, fix or cut, with a one-line reason), both written for romance manuscriptsDevelopmental Critique $20. Scene Map $12. Instant Score free with a free Cadet account

Where does Authors Starport differ from Fictionary?

  • Who does the judging. Fictionary gives you scene feedback and a step-by-step journey, and you turn them into edits. In Starport the Scene Map scores every scene keep, fix or cut and gives the reason, and the Developmental Critique writes the letter. You decide what to act on.
  • What you get. Starport gives you the verdict and the worklist, without the scene-by-scene method.
  • Billing. Fictionary is a monthly or annual subscription. Starport sells each tool as a one-off run: $12 for a Scene Map and $20 for a Developmental Critique.
  • Genre. Fictionary lists genre-specific templates, so check which genres it covers before you subscribe. Starport's tools are written for romance manuscripts.

What Starport does not do: it has no outlining templates, no story visualizations and no step-by-step editing journey, and it is not a place to write. Its tools read a manuscript or check a book idea against the market. If you want those features, Fictionary lists them.

Should you use Fictionary or a read-it-for-you tool?

Use Fictionary if you want to build the skill of structural editing and are willing to work through the scenes. Its StoryTeller page lists a step-by-step editing journey, and its free trial needs no card.

Use a read-it-for-you tool if you want one letter and a scene worklist for the whole manuscript instead of working through scene-by-scene feedback. To compare cheaply, run Starport's free Instant Score and the free First-Chapter Autopsy on your manuscript, then put the output next to a Fictionary trial on the same book.

Related comparisons and free reads

Other tools in the same decision: Marlowe alternatives · AutoCrit alternatives · ProWritingAid alternatives · book editing software, by category · what a manuscript evaluation actually is.

Two free reads before you subscribe to anything: the Manuscript Scorecard grades the whole manuscript, and the First-Chapter Autopsy reads your opening 5,000 words.

Why this comes from real manuscripts and real readers

Authors Starport is a full editing suite — developmental critique, a line edit delivered as tracked changes, a style sheet built from your own prose, a scene map and an instant score — and every one of those tools is grounded in what real readers actually respond to. Behind them sit real reader reviews, book blurbs analyzed for hook, stakes and tone, and reader personas built from that data.

Compared with Fictionary, a structural self-editing tool built for DIY writers, Starport reads the manuscript and returns the verdict as an editorial letter and a keep, fix or cut map of your scenes.

Find out where your manuscript actually stands — free.

The Manuscript Scorecard grades your full manuscript on nine craft metrics, measures it against a reference set of Coral Hart's prose, and tells you exactly what to fix first. Free, in minutes.

Get your free Manuscript Scorecard →

FAQ

What is a good Fictionary alternative?

ProWritingAid, AutoCrit and Marlowe each list a report on the whole manuscript, and Authors Starport offers an editorial letter and a keep, fix or cut map of your scenes, written for romance. Which fits depends on who should do the reading: if you want another framework to work through scene by scene, a structure tool is closest. We make Starport, so test it on the free tools first.

Is there a free Fictionary alternative?

Several tools list a free way in. AutoCrit lists a Free Forever plan, ProWritingAid lists a free plan, and Authors Starport's Instant Score is free with a free account, as is its First-Chapter Autopsy (one run per account). Fictionary itself lists a 7-day free trial with no credit card. Terms were checked on October 20, 2026.

How much does Fictionary cost?

Fictionary lists StoryTeller at $19 per month or $14 per month billed annually ($168), and StoryTeller Premium at $39 per month or $29 per month billed annually ($348). All plans are in USD with a 7-day free trial and no credit card. Prices were checked on October 20, 2026.

Is Fictionary worth it for romance authors?

It can be, if you want to learn structural editing and will work through the scenes yourself. Fictionary lists genre-specific templates, so check which genres are included. If you would rather have the notes handed back for a romance manuscript, a read-it-for-you tool such as Authors Starport's Developmental Critique and Scene Map may suit better.

How is Authors Starport different from Fictionary?

Fictionary gives you a framework, visualizations and an editing journey, and you turn the insights into edits. Starport reads the manuscript and returns the verdict: a Developmental Critique and a Scene Map that scores every scene keep, fix or cut. Starport has no outlining templates or visualizations, and its tools are written for romance.

Can I use Fictionary and Authors Starport together?

Yes. Fictionary suits the scene-by-scene work of learning structure, and Starport suits a second opinion on a finished draft. The free Instant Score and First-Chapter Autopsy let you compare the output with your own Fictionary notes before you pay for anything.

More guides