← All guides
Tools, compared

AutoCrit vs ProWritingAid: which is better for fiction?

AutoCrit and ProWritingAid get compared constantly because they sit on the same shelf: self-editing tools that analyse a manuscript and report back. They are not the same tool. AutoCrit is an editing platform with fiction-focused reports and guided editing by genre; ProWritingAid is a writing assistant that works inside Word, Google Docs and Scrivener and also lists a group of Story Critique tools. Here is the clear-eyed comparison — and the disclosure that Authors Starport competes with both, so weigh our view of the gap they share accordingly.

The short version

  • Pick AutoCrit if you write fiction, want reports and guided editing built around fiction genres (romance is one of them), and like working in a dedicated editing platform. Its Pro plans add Story Analyzer+ and automated alpha and beta readers.
  • Pick ProWritingAid if you also write non-fiction, want a wide set of grammar and style reports (Premium lists 25+), and need it inside Word, Google Docs, Scrivener or the browser. Its story-level tools are separate and credit-based.
  • Pick neither as your only tool if you want the line edit done for you as tracked changes in Word. That is a different category.

Rival features above are as listed on AutoCrit's pricing page and ProWritingAid's pricing page on October 20, 2026.

Category by category

CategoryAutoCritProWritingAid
Built forAn editing platform for fiction and non-fiction, with guided editing by genreA writing assistant for many kinds of writing, with a Story Critique group of tools
Grammar and spellingA spelling and grammar checker is listedGrammar, spelling and punctuation checks, including on the free plan
Prose-pattern reportsPacing and momentum, dialogue, strong writing, word choice, repetition and readability reportsPremium lists 25+ writing analysis reports and a custom style guide
Genre comparisonLists a genre comparison score and a way to compare your style with major genresPremium lists a comparison of your writing with 90 fiction authors across genres
Story and structureStory Analyzer+ (Pro plans): premise, conflict, characters, timeline, foreshadowing, with manuscripts mapped against structures that include romanceStory Critique tools: Chapter Critique, Plot Analysis, Character Analysis, Manuscript Analysis (up to 300,000 words, bought with credits), Virtual Beta Reader, Marketability Analysis
Does it make the edits?Interactive editing tools and reports; you apply the changesSuggestions and Rephrases in the editor; you apply them
IntegrationsWriting platform; ePub and print PDF exportWeb editor, Word, Google Docs and Scrivener
PricingBoth are subscription tools with plans set by the vendor, and both change their tiers, so check each site for current pricing. We don't quote rivals' prices here.

What they share, and what neither lists

Both are report-driven tools, and both now sell story-level analysis next to the sentence-level reports. That is why authors comparing them often end up reading an AutoCrit alternative or a ProWritingAid alternative guide. Two things are worth knowing before you pick either:

  • The story-level read costs extra or sits on a higher tier. AutoCrit lists Story Analyzer+ with its Pro plans. ProWritingAid sells Manuscript Analysis with credits, separate from the subscription, and says on its own page that Manuscript Analysis is not meant to replace a human developmental editor or beta reader.
  • Neither lists a line edit returned as tracked changes in your Word file. Both give you reports and suggestions to apply yourself; across a novel that is hundreds of decisions to interpret and type.

The done-for-you version is what Authors Starport is built for: a Developmental Critique written as an editorial letter cited to your text, a Line Edit that builds a Style Sheet from your own prose and renders the edits as tracked changes in your Word file, a Scene Map, and an Instant Score that covers the metrics ground. Some authors keep AutoCrit or ProWritingAid for diagnosis and use Starport to do the work; the overlap is mostly on metrics.

Our verdict

For a fiction writer choosing between the two, AutoCrit's fiction-focused reports and genre tools make it the more fiction-literate platform; ProWritingAid's breadth and integrations make it the better all-round writing assistant. If what you want is a finished line edit as tracked changes in your own voice, neither lists that, and the cheapest way to check ours is the free Manuscript Scorecard on the manuscript you have now.

Why this comes from real manuscripts and real readers

Authors Starport is a full editing suite — developmental critique, a line edit delivered as tracked changes, a style sheet built from your own prose, a scene map and an instant score — and every one of those tools is grounded in what real readers actually respond to. Behind them sit real reader reviews, book blurbs analyzed for hook, stakes and tone, and reader personas built from that data.

Compared with AutoCrit and ProWritingAid, which are subscription tools built around reports and suggestions you apply yourself, Starport builds a Style Sheet from your own manuscript and hands the line edit back as tracked changes in your Word file.

Find out where your manuscript actually stands — free.

The Manuscript Scorecard grades your full manuscript on nine craft metrics, measures it against a reference set of Coral Hart's prose, and tells you exactly what to fix first. Free, in minutes.

Get your free Manuscript Scorecard →

FAQ

Is AutoCrit or ProWritingAid better for novels?

AutoCrit is the more fiction-focused of the two: its pricing page lists guided editing for fiction genres including romance, a genre comparison score and, on the Pro plans, Story Analyzer+. ProWritingAid lists the broader set of grammar and style reports and integrates with Word, Google Docs and Scrivener. Both also list story-level tools, so check each pricing page for what your plan includes. Checked October 20, 2026.

Can AutoCrit or ProWritingAid do a developmental edit?

Both offer story-level analysis, which is not the same as a human editor. AutoCrit's Story Analyzer+ covers premise, conflict, characters, timeline and foreshadowing, and ProWritingAid's Manuscript Analysis is, by its own page, not meant to replace a human developmental editor or beta reader. For an editorial letter cited to your chapters, Authors Starport's Developmental Critique is another option.

Do AutoCrit or ProWritingAid make the edits?

Both give you reports and suggestions that you apply yourself, and neither lists a whole-manuscript line edit returned as tracked changes in your document. Authors Starport's Line Edit does that, measured against a Style Sheet built from your own prose.

Which is cheaper, AutoCrit or ProWritingAid?

Both are subscription tools whose tiers change, so check each site for current pricing rather than relying on any comparison page, including this one. Authors Starport's pricing is on our plans page and is pay-as-you-go by tool.

More guides