The right AutoCrit alternative depends on why you are leaving: ProWritingAid for sentence-level checks, Fictionary for scene-by-scene structure work, Marlowe for a single story report, or Authors Starport if you want the line edit done for you as tracked changes in Word.
One thing to know up front: Authors Starport is a competing tool, so this page is a maker's case, not a neutral review. Every price and feature below for another tool is what that company lists on its own site as of October 20, 2026. Plans change, so check the linked page before you buy.
AutoCrit is an editing platform for fiction and non-fiction writers. As listed on its pricing page on October 20, 2026, it includes:
That list is broader than many older write-ups describe. AutoCrit now offers story-level analysis as well as sentence-level reports, so a comparison that says it only checks prose patterns is out of date.
| Plan | Price listed | What the page says it includes |
|---|---|---|
| Free Forever | $0 per month | Writing platform with no word limits, noteboards and cards, and select editing tools including Adverbs, Word Choice and Readability |
| Pro Monthly | $30 per month | Everything in Free, plus 25+ editing tools and advanced reports, Story Analyzer+, automated alpha and beta readers, Market Fuel, and ePub and print PDF export |
| Pro Annual | $15 per month, billed annually | Everything in Pro Monthly. The page shows it as 50% off the monthly price |
Annual billing at $15 per month comes to $180 a year. Source: AutoCrit pricing, checked October 20, 2026.
| Tool | What its own site says it does | Price as listed |
|---|---|---|
| ProWritingAid | Grammar and style checks, 25+ writing analysis reports on Premium, and story-level reports (Manuscript Analysis, Plot Analysis, Character Analysis, Virtual Beta Reader) sold with credits | Free plan. Premium $10 per month billed yearly, or $30 billed monthly. Lifetime $399 |
| Fictionary StoryTeller | Scene-by-scene structure software with genre-specific templates, scene feedback, 15 visualizations and a Story Map. Its pricing page calls it story structure software for DIY writers | $19 per month, or $14 per month billed annually. 7-day free trial, no card |
| Marlowe (Authors A.I.) | A developmental report on plot, character, pacing, story beats, narrative drive and theme, compared with bestsellers in your genre. Takes .docx or ePub, 20,000 words minimum. It says it never writes or rewrites your text | Reports start at $29.95 for a single report. Basic and Pro subscriptions are also listed |
| Authors Starport | Tools for romance manuscripts, each sold as a one-off run: a free Instant Score, a Developmental Critique (editorial letter), a Scene Map, a Style Sheet, and a Line Edit returned as tracked changes in your Word file | Instant Score free with a free Cadet account. Developmental Critique $20, Scene Map $12, Style Sheet $7, Line Edit $50. Go For Launch bundle $80 to $120 by length |
None of these is best at everything. If you mainly want a subscription with reports, AutoCrit and ProWritingAid sit closest together. If you want to work through structure scene by scene, Fictionary lists a step-by-step editing journey. If you want a standalone report, Marlowe lists one; if you want the edits delivered, Starport does that. More head-to-heads: our AutoCrit review, AutoCrit vs ProWritingAid, AutoCrit vs Grammarly, ProWritingAid alternatives, Fictionary alternatives and Marlowe alternatives.
What Starport does not do: it is not a writing environment, because the tools page lists checks and edits you run on a book idea or a manuscript, not a place to draft. It has no automated alpha or beta readers. It has no dedicated dialogue tags report, though Instant Score measures adverb density, filter words and repetition across the whole manuscript. If you need those, AutoCrit lists them.
Stay with AutoCrit if you write outside romance, want a writing environment and reports under one subscription, or want a free tier to start on. Its free plan is the cheapest way to see what its tools do.
Look at Starport if you write romance, you would rather buy one run at a time than subscribe, and you want the sentence-level work done for you in Word instead of worked through on a dashboard. To compare fairly, run the free Instant Score and AutoCrit's free plan on the same manuscript and keep whichever notes you would act on. Nothing stops you using both.
Authors Starport is a full editing suite — developmental critique, a line edit delivered as tracked changes, a style sheet built from your own prose, a scene map and an instant score — and every one of those tools is grounded in what real readers actually respond to. Behind them sit real reader reviews, book blurbs analyzed for hook, stakes and tone, and reader personas built from that data.
Compared with AutoCrit, which is a subscription platform with interactive reports, Starport sells each tool as a one-off run, and its Line Edit measures every change against a Style Sheet built from your own prose.
The Manuscript Scorecard grades your full manuscript on nine craft metrics, measures it against a reference set of Coral Hart's prose, and tells you exactly what to fix first. Free, in minutes.
Get your free Manuscript Scorecard →Yes. AutoCrit's pricing page lists a Free Forever plan at $0 per month, with the writing platform and select editing tools including Adverbs, Word Choice and Readability. The Pro plans add the advanced reports, Story Analyzer+ and automated alpha and beta readers. Checked October 20, 2026.
AutoCrit lists Pro Monthly at $30 per month and Pro Annual at $15 per month billed annually, which is $180 a year. A Free Forever plan is also listed. These are the prices on its pricing page on October 20, 2026, so check it before you buy.
Yes. Its pricing page lists Story Analyzer+ on the Pro plans, and the Story Analyzer+ page lists conflict, characters, timeline, foreshadowing and genre analysis, with romance among the structures it maps against. If you want an editorial letter written for a romance manuscript, Authors Starport's Developmental Critique is $20 per run.
Three tools list a romance-relevant answer: Fictionary has genre-specific templates, Marlowe compares your book with bestsellers in your genre, and Authors Starport is written for romance and does the line edit for you as tracked changes. We make Starport, so test it on the free Instant Score before you decide.
Yes. They do different jobs: AutoCrit is a subscription with interactive reports, and Starport sells each tool as a one-off run. Instant Score is free with a free account, so you can compare its nine measurements with AutoCrit's reports on the same manuscript before paying for anything.
That depends on how much of the editing you want to do yourself. AutoCrit's annual plan works out to $15 per month and its free plan lets you try select tools first. If you mainly want the edits made for you in Word, a one-off run such as Starport's $50 Line Edit may suit better. If you want a writing environment and ongoing reports, a subscription may.